PAPER C
Purpose
: For Decision
REPORT
TO THE CABINET
Date : 30 AUGUST 2005
Title : CHANGE
MANAGEMENT
REPORT OF THE LEADER OF THE COUNCIL
IMPLEMENTATION DATE : 12 September 2005
1.
To approve a revised structure to enable the Council
to implement the emerging Change Management Plan.
RULE 15
ACCESS TO INFORMATION RULES
2.
This report appeared on the Forward Plan for decision on
28 September 2005, as part of the Change Management Plan. Consultation on
changes to service delivery structures was completed on time, allowing the
timetable for implementing the proposed changes to be brought forward. The
changes proposed will help to deliver a high performing, cost effective Council
and there is no reason to delay approval and implementation until the planned
decision date.
BACKGROUND
3.
Work has been underway over recent weeks on developing
a Change Management Plan for the Council.
4.
The first stage of this was to set out revised
proposals for the way in which the Council is to function. The Council has indicated its wish to focus
its priorities around four clear service blocks with those blocks mirroring the
political arrangements made by the Council and the four themes which will
comprise the Local Area Agreement.
These arrangements will provide a clear link between the community
priorities and the Council’s ability to respond effectively to them.
5.
The proposed structure for the Council as shown in
Appendix A will, in future, be focused around the four service directorates of:
·
Children’s Services
·
Adult and Community Services
·
Economic Development and Regeneration
·
Safer Communities
6.
Changes to management structures will follow adoption
of the new organisational structure.
7.
In respect of the centre of the organisation, it is
proposed to appoint two Assistant Chief Executives who will have responsibility
for delivering within the Chief Executive’s Department, the overall Change
Management Plan and the internal operation of the Council. This arrangement will free the Chief
Executive to support the Leader in developing the role of the Council as a community
leader and in strengthening its partnership approach.
8.
The structure also anticipates the appointment of a
new Head of Communications to work to improve the public profile of the
Council. That post would report through
the Assistant Chief Executives. Within
the Economic Development and Regeneration block it is proposed that a new Head
of Regeneration be recruited to focus the Council’s approach to regeneration
and to link relevant groups of staff within that Directorate who are being
drawn increasingly towards this type of work.
9.
For the time being, the post of Head of Housing
Services has been retained in the structure.
This is an area currently under review by the Commission and until that
review has been completed, no steps will be taken to recruit to that post.
10.
A Change Agent is to be recruited through external
advertisement. Competitive quotations
are being obtained at the present time and, subject to that process, the Change
Agent should be appointed by the end of September. The brief for the Change Agent will be as follows:
Using the IDeA procurement model to identify
and implement opportunities to improve identified services provided by the
Council and partners.
A key element of the project will be the
Council’s ability to review the progress made in each phase of the model and to
agree progression to subsequent phases.
·
Evaluate whether a Strategic Partnership can deliver improvements in the
efficiency, effectiveness and economy of Council operations against seeking to achieve
the changes purely in-house;
·
Identify which support and direct services could be delivered through
such a partnership;
·
Identify efficiency services through re-engineering of processes for
those services before implementing a Strategic Partnership.
·
Evaluate the various options for implementing a Strategic Partnership.
·
Prepare an impact assessment for preferred option, to show its potential
effect on the whole Island economy.
Then,
dependent on the decision taken at the feasibility stage:
·
Procure a strategic partner, including:
-
going to the market
-
briefing potential suppliers
-
evaluating bids
-
appointing a preferred supplier
-
negotiating a contract
·
Preparation for and Transition of services to the partnership
·
During all stages of the Initiative to communicate effectively with all
of its staff and stakeholders.
The chosen
consultants will be required to work collaboratively with the Council at all
times (defining precisely the methodology by which and the personnel with whom;
they will do this) and seek to optimise knowledge and competence transfer to
the Council’s staff.
11.
In essence, the role for the Change Manager will be to
identify efficiency savings within the “in scope” services and then assess on a
business case basis the case for including individual services in a strategic
partnering contract. The initial “in
scope” services will be:
·
ICT
·
Customer Services (including the one-stop shops and
other frontline service points to be agreed)
·
Revenues and Benefits
·
Exchequer Services
·
Procurement
·
The non-strategic parts of the HR department
·
The Building Management and Maintenance parts of
Property Services
12.
The plan has been the subject of extensive
consultation with staff on an individual and collective basis and also with
UNISON. Their views are referred to
under the consultation part of this report.
13.
These structural changes form the first part of an
overall Change Management Plan. This
Plan has been drafted by a small team over the last few weeks. They have interviewed each Head of Service,
have mapped all the manifesto commitments and analysed the different resources
required to deliver those commitments.
Annex 1 to this report demonstrates how this work is being pulled
together.
14.
Although there are pockets of excellent service within
the Council, the thrust of the Change Management Plan is that the Council needs
to raise its game across the whole organisation rather than in individual
components. Without a whole Council
approach, it will be much more difficult to meet the aspiration of the Island
for us to become a “high-performing and cost-effective council”.
15.
Delivery of the Plan will not be effective unless
there is significant change in the way in which staff are engaged, work is
prioritised and communication and consultation channels enhanced. The Plan proposes that five priority
objective groups are established. Beneath
each of these groups will be a small number of “Aim High Teams”. These teams will be drawn from across the
organisation with a view to engaging a wide number of staff in this Change
Plan.
16.
This is a significant period of change for the
Council. To that end, a period of
consultation on the draft Change Management Plan has commenced and is intended
to run through until 9 September. A key
part of that consultation process will be a staff conference in the first week
in September for around 150 middle managers.
17.
The Cabinet Secretaries have agreed to work with the
Change Team to ensure that all the different commitments are properly reflected
in the Plan.
18.
The intention is that the Plan will be brought back to
the Cabinet for formal approval on 27 September. The Cabinet is not scheduled to meet until 11 October but is
asked to agree to hold a special meeting on 27 September to allow the Plan to
be considered.
19.
In order to reflect the priorities of the new
administration and to link with the four key themes of the Local Area
Agreement, the Council is to be recommended that its own Corporate Plan is
based around five clear corporate priorities:
·
Create safer communities
·
Drive the economic development and regeneration of the
Island
·
Improve facilities and services for children and young
people
·
Improve the health of communities and older people
·
Run a high-performing cost-effective council
20.
The Council has already adopted the Island’s 2020
vision. The Change Management Plan will
recommend a way in which the Council’s own vision can establish a clear link
with the 2020 aspirations for the whole Island as well as the identified
outcomes for the forthcoming Local Area Agreement.
CONSULTATION
21.
As indicated above, there has been wide-ranging
consultation with staff across the Council, with UNISON and also with some
external partners. The general issues
to emerge from the consultation are set out below with a response in respect of
the point raised:
(a)
From some external partners and from a wide range of staff,
concern about the potential impact of strategic partnering, its potential
threat to jobs on the Island and concerns that there must be a clear business
case and risk assessment before the Council embarks down this path. The brief for the Change Manager which is
set out above is geared to ensure that this very approach is adopted and to
ensure that the Council has the best advice before moving forward.
(b)
A number of representations have been made about the
role of the environment within the Council’s priorities. Protecting and enhancing the environment is
one of the Council’s existing six priorities but this is not directly reflected
in the proposed five corporate priorities for this new Council. It will be seen from Appendix B to this
report that protecting and enhancing the environment is identified as a
specific aim of the Council even though it does not feature in one of the top
five level priorities.
(c)
A range of views about the need for and potential
impact of change. It is quite clear
that the Council performs well in some parts of its operations. There is however no consistent pattern to
performance nor indeed to, for example, the way in which the Council deals with
its customers. The overall Change
Management Plan is geared towards moving the Council towards a high performing
and cost effective organisation.
Without the adoption of the Plan and tackling these issues as a single
organisation, the prospects of the Council achieving a higher score than “fair”
in next year’s Comprehensive Performance Assessment will be difficult.
22.
Specific representations have been received from
UNISON. These views are attached as
Appendix C to this report so that the full extent of their views are conveyed
to Elected Members.
FINANCIAL/BUDGET
IMPLICATIONS
23.
As a strategic priority, the new Council has indicated
its wish to invest to increase the corporate capacity to deliver the change
agenda. The anticipated estimated
additional salary costs of implementing this revised structure will be in the
order of £34,500 plus on costs in a full financial year. The part-year effect of this will need to be
met from within the Council’s existing resources with suitable adjustments
being made as the Council adopts its budget for 2006/07. The overall cost of service delivery will
fall from 2006/07 following adoption of the new structure, through delivery of
the Change Management Plan and consequent changes to the establishment and
development of staff, and the economies of scale conseqeunt.
24.
At the time of preparing this report, the cost of the
organisational Change Manager is not yet known as formal quotations are still
awaited. Investment in a Change Manager
will need to be covered by means of a separate report to the Cabinet on 28
September. However, the expectation is
that the investment in the Change Manager will be funded over a period of time
by increased efficiencies that the Change Manager helps to deliver.
LEGAL
IMPLICATIONS
25.
The organisation of staff is the responsibility of the
Chief Executive (as Head of Paid Service).
The organisation of strategic and service delivery structures is,
however, the responsibility of the Cabinet in ensuring the delivery of
continually improving services.
Approval of the structures as recommended will enable the deployment of
staff in order to meet the objectives of the Change Management Plan.
26.
Consequent changes to the Constitution will need to be
made. These will be effected using
delegations wherever possible.
27.
The proposed management structure has been drafted as
a response to the manifesto commitments set by the new administration and as a
clear means for delivering on those issues.
The change agenda will be a significant challenge for the Council. Without investment in dedicated change
management skills, there will be a real danger that progress is not
sustained. By way of example, the
former Council adopted the GAGS programme as a way of championing the interests
of the customer. Organisational change
has proven to be extremely difficult to achieve and demonstrates the need for
specific and focused skills if change of this type is anticipated.
28.
Subject to the approval of the Cabinet to the revised management
structure, the appointment process for the two Assistant Chief Executives, the
Head of Regeneration and the Head of Communications will take place during
September. In accordance with the
Council’s Protocols, these appointments will be on a cross-party basis. Arrangements are already in hand for the
recruitment of a new Director for Adult and Community Services with interviews
scheduled for 26 and 27 September. The
appointment process for the Director of Safer Communities is likely to be commenced
during September.
29.
As indicated above, the Cabinet is invited to agree to
convene a special meeting on 28 September with a view to adopting the formal
Change Management Plan.
RECOMMENDATIONS (i)
That the Council adopts the revised structure as
shown at Appendix A. (ii)
That the Cabinet hold a special meeting on 28
September to consider the Change Management Plan and the appointment of a
Change Agent. |
Click here to view Appendix C
Contact
Point : Mike Fisher, Chief Executive, ( 3102 email
: [email protected]
MR
MIKE FISHER Chief
Executive |
CLLR
ANDY SUTTON Leader
of the Council |
OBJECTIVES |
The
Island in 2020 |
LSP Outcomes |
AIMS |
TARGETS (examples) |
Our objectives are: |
We
will: |
We
will have been successful if we: |
||
Create safer
communities |
1. 2. 3. 4. |
|
Address drug and alcohol misuse |
Reduce the number of arrests
associated with drug and alcohol misuse by x% by Y |
|
Improve community support and enforcement |
Increase the percentage of
people who say they feel safe on the island by x% by Y |
||
|
Improve public transport |
Increase the number of
journeys made on public transport by x% by Y |
||
|
Improve road safety |
Reduce the number of fatal
incidents on island roads by x% by Y and the number of non-fatal incidents by
x% by Y |
||
|
Provide an
effective fire and rescue service |
Reduce the number of deaths
from fire related incidents by x% by Y and the overall number of fires by x%
by Y |
||
Drive the
economic development and regeneration of the island |
1. 2. 3. 4. |
|
Create a robust economic infrastructure |
Increase the level of
employment on the island to at least the national average level by Y |
|
Increase inward investment |
Increase the average level
of spend per visitor to the island from £W to £X by Y, and the average level
of government / European funding from £X to £Y per head by 2009 |
||
|
Increase the prosperity of individuals |
Increase average levels of
income per person to at least the national average by Y |
||
|
Increase the prosperity of local businesses |
Increase the number of local
contracts awarded to island companies by X% by Y |
||
Improve
facilities and services for children and young people |
1. 2. 3. 4. |
|
Address problem areas to do with young children |
Increase the percentage of
schools reporting an improvement in the way problem areas are addressed by X%
by Y |
|
Improve services for vulnerable children |
Increase the percentage of looked
after children and carers who say they are satisfied with the services
provided for them by X% by Y whilst reducing the overall number of looked
after children by X% by Y |
||
|
Improve the health, safety, enjoyment, contribution and well being of
children |
Achieve a score at least as
good as the national average on all of the ‘Every Child Matters’ indicators
by Y |
||
|
Improve the quality of education on the island |
Increase educational attainment
levels to at least the national average on all standard measures by Y and to
the top quartile position by Z |
||
Improve the
health of communities and older people |
1. 2. 3. 4. |
|
Improve health and social care |
Reduce the number of deaths at
less than 75 by x% by Y and increase user / carer satisfaction of home care
to at least X% by Y |
|
Improve housing and reduce homelessness |
Increase the stock of
affordable housing on the island to X by Y and reduce the number of homeless
islanders to X by Y |
||
|
Increase the level of community engagement |
Increase the number of
people participating in local area management from W to X by Y and increase
voter turnout at elections by x% by Y |
||
|
Protect and enhance the environment |
Increase public satisfaction
with the way the environment is managed from w% to x% by Y |
||
Run a high
performing, low spending council |
1. 2. 3. 4. |
|
Focus on the customer |
Resolve 80% or more of
enquiries on first contact with an overall customer satisfaction level of 85%
or more and an overall customer satisfaction level for all services of 80% or
more. |
|
Improve governance |
Improve the public’s
perception of the openness and competence of the council |
||
|
Reduce costs |
Hold the council tax at the
rate of inflation or less for the next four years, and bring the council into
line with the most frugal unitary authorities by the 2009 |
||
|
Work in partnership with others |
Procure strategic partnership
arrangements in accordance with national best practice which add significant
value to the council |
||
|
Ensure robust processes, practices and infrastructure |
Achieve an overall CPA score
for the authority of “Good” in 2006 and of “Excellent” by 2009 |