PAPER C

 

                                                                                                                Purpose : for Decision

                        REPORT TO THE EXECUTIVE

 

Date :              19 NOVEMBER 2003

 

                        PLANNING SERVICES – BEST VALUE REVIEW

                       

REPORT OF THE PORTFOLIO HOLDER FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT, AND PLANNING POLICY

 

IMPLEMENTATION DATE : 1 December 2003

 


SUMMARY/PURPOSE

 

1.                  To approve the findings of the Best Value Review of Planning Services and the planned actions contained within the report.

 

BACKGROUND

 

2.                  The Best Value Review of Planning Services has been carried out as part of the IW Council programme of reviews.   Scoping of the review was commenced in November 2002, and Executive approval will complete the review within the planned timescale. The main issues highlighted by the review are contained within the Report attached as Appendix 1.

 

STRATEGIC CONTEXT


 

3.                  The Government is seeking to improve Planning Services through the new Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill (currently scheduled for Spring 2004), which will see the replacement of the Unitary Development Plan (UDP) by a new Local Development Framework (LDF).   The development of the LDF will connect up with the Community Strategy (Island Futures) and help deliver the policies it contains.

 

Planning Services will therefore become a more pro-active service and provide sustainable development, whilst protecting the local environment.  This will support the IW Council’s six main corporate objectives.  It will also be able to support national and regional government objectives.

 

The Improvement Plan has been designed around existing best practice.   Its five key themes are based on the Audit Commission’s report on Planning Services: -

 

·        Focussing on what matters to local people

·        Assuring the quality of development

·        Enhancing customer care

·        Reducing the delay in Development Control

·        Reinforcing management systems to assure quality

 

 

These key themes have given the Improvement Plan a robust structure and has encouraged the component teams in the service to work together on these more general objectives rather than prepare their own component improvement plan.

 

The aim is to make Planning Services an excellent service and one of the leading 25% of all local planning authorities by 2007.

 

The improvements contained within the report support these changes over the next four years, through the departments service planning.

 

CONSULTATION

 

4.                  Key external and internal stakeholders have given their views on the Planning Services and have suggested improvements.

 

Those involved have included:-

 

                        Officers of Planning Services, and the Project Team

Members of Economic Development, Planning, Tourism & Leisure  Select Committee

Development Control Committee and the Member Appraisal Group.

                        Major organisations such as English Heritage, Environment Agency

                        IWC Departments who work with Planning Services

                        Occasional Users of the Service – surveyed at Seaclose.

                        MORI – Citizens Panel – postal survey of awareness & effectiveness

                        Best Value Inspectorate – external challenge visit.

The New Unitaries Benchmarking Group – performance & good practice comparisons.

                        GOSE – external challenge visit

                        East Riding of Yorkshire Council – external challenge visit

                        Agents & Architects Focus Group – planned meetings.

 

These have all informed the review and the findings of the report.  In particular, the visits from a Best Value Inspector (June 2003) and the Head of Planning Services from East Riding of Yorkshire Council (September 2003) have given an early steer and an external reality check respectively.

 

FINANCIAL/BUDGET IMPLICATIONS

 

5.         The financial implication are outlined in the report and detailed in the Service Plan for 2004/05.   

 

LEGAL IMPLICATIONS

 

6.         Best Value Reviews are a statutory obligation under the Local Government Act 1999 and subsequent circulars.  The local methodology delivers the required standard of review.

 

7.         The Planning Service combines a number of statutory functions, some of which are subject to review by the Planning Inspectorate, and each of which has a role to play in the delivery of corporate objectives.  Where there is a legal context to the review and its recommendations, these are considered in the report.

 

OPTIONS

 

1. To endorse the Best Value Review and to approve the implementation of the improvement plan.

 

2.   To request more work to be carried out.

 

EVALUATION/RISK MANAGEMENT

 

8.         Improvements to Planning Services will be a part of the implementation of the IW Council’s Community Strategy, and will make the service more customers orientated.  It will also help to plan the future land use of the Island in a sustainable manner, and to protect the environment. 

 

9.                  Improved performance is crucial to the achievement of additional funding of the service through Supplementary Planning Grant.  The Report shows how we plan to improve performance in line with government targets and how we will produce a Local Development Framework by 2007. 

 

10.             The main risk to this plan is therefore lack of performance by Planning Services. Recent performance has shown that they can meet and exceed the key performance targets.  That risk can be further minimised by the support of IW Council for these planned improvements.  Detailed risk assessments have already been provided to the County Treasurer and the Insurance & Risk Manager.

 

 

RECOMMENDATIONS

 

11.             To approve option 1.

 

BACKGROUND PAPERS

 

12.             The detailed improvement plan (Part 3 of the Report), the main report and the appendices to the report. 

 

Contact Point :David Hughes 824553 [email protected] 

 

A ASHCROFT

Head of Planning Services

T BUTCHERS

Portfolio Holder for Sustainable Development, Environment, and Planning Policy