PAPER B

 

 

ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, PLANNING, TOURISM AND LEISURE SERVICES SELECT COMMITTEE – 10 FEBRUARY 2005

 

THE DRAFT SOUTH EAST PLAN

 

REPORT OF THE PORTFOLIO HOLDER FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING POLICY

 

 

REASON FOR SELECT COMMITTEE CONSIDERATION

 

To enable consideration by the committee of issues in relation to the SE Plan and the Special Policies for the Isle of Wight (contained within it).

 

 

ACTION REQUIRED BY THE SELECT COMMITTEE

 

i)      To receive information from the portfolio holder about the Draft SE Plan.

 

ii)    To make recommendations to the Executive as part of its comments to SEERA on the SE Plan.

 

 

BACKGROUND

 

The South East Plan, will set the regional context for development, and when eventually approved by Government, it will provide a statutory regional framework for development to 2026, setting out scale, priorities and broad locations for change.  It will integrate with other key regional strategies and with the new local planning system, operating through Local Development Documents.  It places particular emphasis on measures to achieve implementation and delivery.

 

The consultation draft is the first stage in formulation of the Plan.  It sets out the main elements for debate and seeks views on development options and other issues.  The Plan can be viewed in full on SEERA’s website www.southeast-ra.gov.uk

 

The consultation draft contains one significant and deliberate omission:  district level housing targets.  These will be an important component of the plan and will form the basis of a second stage of consultation later in 2005.

 

The Assembly is consulting on a range of development options, at both the regional and sub-regional levels.  The three growth options for the region as a whole are:

 

1.      25,500 additional homes per annum – a lower figure than current planned rate.

 

2.      28,000 additional homes per annum – approximately the current planned rate.

 

3.      32,000 additional homes per annum – higher than the current planned rate.

 


In addition to 3 options for growth there are also 2 options for distribution of growth across the region:

 

1.      Continuation of existing policy – essentially a roll forward of the pattern of development established in existing regional planning guidance.

 

2.      Sharper Focus – a variation which places more emphasis on a combination of areas requiring regeneration and areas with notable economic potential.

 

The maps which illustrate the link between the options and distribution of growth are included at Appendix 1.

 

A set of regional policies, to set priorities and targets and guide action, forms a core component of the Plan.   The principal policies are précised in Appendix 2 and the bullet points relate to what local authorities will be expected to consider as part of their LDF.

 

Implications for the Isle of Wight

 

Four options have been identified by the Isle of Wight Council for the future role of the Island.

 

Option ARates of housing development would remain at current planned rates (520 homes per annum). Rates of economic development would also continue at current rates. This level of housing development could be accommodated on sites identified through the urban potential study, though densities would need to be higher and more employment sites and car parks would need to be developed for housing. Such a level of growth may not provide for projected household growth and would not erode the existing shortfall in the supply of affordable housing.

 

Option BRates of housing development would increase substantially in order to deal with the existing shortfall in the supply of affordable housing. Rates of economic development would continue at current rates. Housing development at this scale would require higher densities, use of additional previously developed land (including employment sites), additional funding for affordable housing and the release of additional greenfield sites.  There would be increased pressure on existing infrastructure.  Additional investment in infrastructure would be required.

 

Option CRates of housing development would be linked to economic-led regeneration.  To be sustainable such growth would need to minimise resource demands and environmental impacts and ensure that development is of the right quality and quantity.  There would be enhanced prospects for regeneration, more balanced local communities, a more self-contained labour market based on a strengthened local economy and skills enhancement.  Additional investment in infrastructure would be required.

 

Option DThe highest rate of growth would be housing-led. It would require strengthened links with the mainland in the form of enhanced ferry services and reduced journey times. It assumes increased commuting to work on the mainland.  This option would result in increased pressure for the release of greenfield land and enhanced infrastructure.

 

Preferred Option - The Council’s preferred option is C, with a level of housing development of at least 520 additional homes per annum between 2006 and 2026.  This strategy for the Isle of Wight is based on managed economic growth and regeneration to provide for the Island’s particular characteristics and needs. Future development is expected to create wealth and a sustainable economy, to address skills deficits and housing need, to provide for improved public transport infrastructure and to respect the environment, safeguarding biodiversity and areas of landscape and ecological importance.

 

Isle of Wight Special Policies

 

The special policies for the Island have been developed specifically to aid the delivery of Option C.  They are as follows:

 

POLICY IW1:  ENABLING ECONOMIC REGENERATION

 

To help realise a step change in the Isle of Wight’s economic performance and to actively support economic regeneration and renewal, an improved quality tourism product and inward investment, national, regional and other relevant agencies and authorities should give increased priority to investment decisions and other direct support for the island. Key measures should include:

 

i The development of infrastructure and inward investment opportunities in the

Medina Valley

 

ii Support for the development of centres of vocational excellence in the sectors

of composites, marine and aeronautical skills and construction related industries including any associated academic establishments

 

iii Support for inward investment and development to regenerate key areas identified in Ryde, Sandown Bay, Ventnor and West Wight

 

iv Support for urban renewal and intensification particularly where this can secure contributions for improvements in the public realm

 

v The need to improve the tourism offer to one that focuses on a higher quality, higher value product.

 

As an island economy the Isle of Wight has particular characteristics and needs.  Tailored solutions will be required to tackle the problems of unemployment and deprivation. In diversifying the rural economy of the island local partners will need to ensure that all sectors of the local community can be involved in the economy and that it is sensitive to the natural resources, landscape and cultural features.

 

The tourism product on the island has developed over many years and both the quality and range of the accommodation supply is no longer sustainable if the island is to prosper.  The volume of visitors during the peak season causes significant strain on the island’s infrastructure and environment, but does not bring sufficient economic return in terms of investment and job opportunities. A significant volume of the assets employed in this sector of the island’s economy are at risk and are currently migrating to inappropriate alternative housing uses which existing policies are unable to address.

 

The island recognises the need for investment in better quality assets at a volume that the environment and community can accommodate.  This will bring opportunities for the  redevelopment of previously developed land for appropriate uses as part of a deep-seated exit strategy for redundant assets. This strategy will also seek to secure adequate contributions for investment in tourism related infrastructure. The development of tailored tourism development strategies will particularly address:

 

·       support for quality hotel development and conference facilities

 

·       support for appropriate tourism-related retail facilities

 

·       support for tourism-related centres of vocational excellence including any associated academic establishment

 

·       exit strategies for redundant tourism accommodation coupled with contributions to improved  tourism related infrastructure.

 

POLICY IW2:  STRATEGIC TRANSPORT LINKS

 

The Isle of Wight is reliant upon efficient and well managed links to the mainland.  The strategic Cross Solent links should be maintained and improved to provide a service which fits with this role, and should form part of an integrated transport approach developed at the local level.

 

The Isle of Wight is reliant upon good links to the mainland and it is therefore important that cross-Solent links are maintained and improved.  The Regional Transport Strategy has recognised the Importance of improving the transport infrastructure and identified the

development of a new transport interchange at Ryde.

 

The local authority is looking to maintain and improve communications between the island and the mainland as part of a sustainable transport strategy through the Local Development Framework, Local Transport Plan and partnership working with transport operators.   Consideration should be given to the potential to provide a second local transport hub to support regeneration initiatives.

 

POLICY IW3:  INFRASTRUCTURE

 

The planning authorities will ensure that the infrastructure needed to support development in the special policy area is identified during the refinement of the strategy for the special policy area. As part of this work the issues of phasing of development in relationship to the provision of infrastructure will be addressed. Detailed proposals for the timely implementation of the infrastructure required to support further growth will be developed during the refinement of the strategy for the special policy area.

 

POLICY IW4:  RURAL AREAS

 

The quality and character of the rural environment should be maintained and enhanced, while securing necessary change to meet the economic and social needs of local people and visitors. Special consideration should be given to rural priority areas.

 

There are particular issues facing the island’s rural areas which are less accessible and, with fewer job opportunities, suffer from problems of isolation and lower incomes.  The policy approach to implement this strategy will be developed at a local level through the LDF, which will require a tailored and integrated approach that focuses on people as well as places, to help maintain and enhance the environment while encouraging the development of diverse and sustainable  communities.  The local authority will need to work with regional and local partners to develop programmes, which encourage enterprise in the rural economy as well as initiatives to sustain diverse rural communities.

 

POLICY IW5:  SCALE AND TYPE OF HOUSING DEVELOPMENT

 

The final version of the strategy will include a policy (or policies) setting out the overall level of housing provision, phasing and the type of housing that will be provided.  In the meantime, the preferred overall level of housing provision is at least 10,400 additional homes over the 20 years 2006 to 2026.

 

The range and type of housing required, together with the distribution and means of implementation will be developed through the LDF. The LDF will need to develop policies to monitor and manage the level of housing provision which clearly link with the objectives of achieving economic regeneration and increasing and improving employment opportunities on the Isle of Wight and the provision of affordable housing.  Higher levels of housing provision will only be expected to be provided once the economic drivers are in place and being implemented and are likely to come into play during later stages of the Plan period.

 

RELEVANT PLANS, POLICIES, STRATEGIES AND PERFORMANCE INDICATORS

 

The statutory planning policy function plays a key role in delivery of targets, and objectives in the Corporate Plan, Community Strategy, UDP, LTP, as well as those of agencies other than the Council.

 

The Local Development Framework will need to conform with the Regional Spatial Strategy – SE Plan and it will be the LDF which will be key to delivering the aims and objectives of the many strategies produced by the Council and other agencies for the foreseeable future.

 

CONSULTATION PROCESS

 

Production of the SE Plan is the responsibility of SEERA.  They have undertaken research and MORI polls across the region and also instigated debates with stakeholders to assist in formulation of the Draft Plan.  As part of the consultation process now underway, SEERA will be sending a leaflet/questionnaire to all households.  The Council has provided links from its website to that for the SE Plan and has arranged advertisements in the County Press.  SEERA have also arranged a meeting for 4 March 2005 at the Riverside Centre with invitations to hard to reach groups. 

 

The Council has requested the inclusion of special policies as part of the SE Plan and has agreed to be involved in the consultation process.

 

FINANCIAL, LEGAL, CRIME AND DISORDER IMPLICATIONS

 

The SE Plan is a formal part of the development plan covered by the Planning & Compulsory Purchase Act 2004. 

 

The costs of the consultation process are being borne by SEERA.

 

APPENDICES ATTACHED

 

1.                  SE Plan Options for Growth and Distribution patterns – Maps

2.                  SE Plan Draft Policies

 

BACKGROUND PAPERS USED IN THE PREPARATION OF THIS REPORT

 

Consultation Draft SE Plan

Isle of Wight Special Policies for the SE Plan

 

Contact Point : Ashley Curzon, ext 5557

 

 

 

COUNCILLOR MRS TERRY BUTCHERS

Portfolio Holder for Sustainable Development, Environment and Planning Policy