SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS at 31 MARCH 2006

Ref		Appellant	Type	Details/site	Appeal Start Date	Procedure/ date of H/I (if known)	Appeal decision and date		Overall duration of appeal (in weeks)
E/25011/A		Mr & Mrs A Court	E	Increased height of house – Edina, Mill Road, Yarmouth	7 Oct 04	I 25 Jan 06	Dismissed 14 Mar 06		73.5
10471/E P/968/04		Mrs Hall	R	Retention of windbreak netting – Timber, Undercliff Drive, St Lawrence	4 Nov 04	WR	Allowed 1 Feb 06		65
4323/T P/1470/04		Mr & Mrs Locke	RL	Demolition of barn and construction of annex; 3 dormer windows to main house – Dodpit House, Dodpits Lane, Newbridge	15 Dec 04	H 17 Jan 06	Dismissed 1 Mar 06		62
4323/U P/1469/04		Mr & Mrs Locke	RL	Listed building application as above	15 Dec 04	H 17 Jan 06	Dismissed 1 Mar 06		62
12116/E P/1835/04		Mr & Mrs Woodford	R	Extension – Little Kitbridge Farm, Forest Road, Newport	2 Feb 05	H 25 May 06
E/10471/F		Mrs Hall	E	Erection of windbreak netting – Timber Undercliff Drive, St Lawrence	3 Feb 05	WR	Allowed 1 Feb 06		53
4323/W P/170/05		Mr & Mrs Locke	R	Demolition of barn and construction of storage building; 3 dormer windows to main house – Dodpits House, Dodpits Lane, Newbridge	26 May 05	H 17 Jan 06	Dismissed 1 Mar 06		40
4323/V P/169/05		Mr & Mrs Locke	RL	Listed building consent application as above	26 May 05	H 17 Jan 06	Dismissed 1 Mar 06		40
E/25508/C		Mr T Smith	E	COU of agricultural land to motocross site – Gore Basin, Downend Road, Newport	10 June 05	WR	Dismissed 26 Jan 06		33
2009/L P/559/05		Mr R Watkins	R	Amendment to agricultural occupancy condition to allow use as annex - Bagwich Farm, Bagwich Lane, Godshill	17 June 05	H
8858/X P/199/05		Peter Robert Harrison 1997 B Settlement	ND	Marine employment, housing, retail, public house/restaurant, hotel, new quay wall – adj River Medina, Cowes	14 July 05	I
25011/A P/19/05		Mr & Mrs A Court	R	Retention of dwelling as constructed- Edina, Mill Road, Yarmouth	28 July 05	I 25 Jan 06	Allowed 14 Mar 06		32.5
4920/X P/00667/05		Mrs L Atwood & Mr C Donoclift	R	Detached house and garage – adjacent Silverleys, High Street, Godshill	9 Sept 05	WR	Dismissed 7 Feb 06		21.5
26435/A P/2670/04		Mr K Wherry	R	Dwelling – adjacent 18 Clarence Road, Newport	9 Sept 05	WR	Allowed 13 Feb 06		22
2647/C P/1187/05		Rotopoint Ltd	R	New roof to section of building to provide 2^nd floor flat – Roundhouse Hotel, 61 George Street, Ryde	13 Sept 05	WR	Dismissed 10 Feb 06		21.5
26475/D P/1183/05		Rotopoint Ltd	RL	Listed building application as above	13 Sept 05	WR	Dismissed 10 Feb 06		21.5
26950 P/563/05		Mr & Mrs Thomson	R	Bungalow – adjacent 9 Lanes End, Totland	13 Sept 05	WR	Allowed 3 Feb 06		20.5
10723/G P/1663/04		Mr M Coventry	R	Agricultural workers dwelling; 12m high wind turbine – Lower Luton Farm, Pallance Lane, Cowes	14 Sept 05	H 6 Jun 06
26589/A P/669/05		Mr J Avey	R	Conversion of house into 2 flats and extension to form 2 addition flats – 97 Clarence Road, East Cowes	23 Sept 05	WR	Dismissed 7 Feb 06		19
1443/05		Mr A Smallman	R	End of terrace house – adjacent 22 Clifford Street, Newport	10 Oct 05	WR	Dismissed 3 Feb 06		16.5
1172/05		Mr & Mrs Proctor	R	Dwelling without parking – land at and rear of Ivy Cottage, Church Lane and fronting New Road, Brading	11 Oct 05	WR	Dismissed 7 Feb 06		17
2524/03		Mr J Rowlands	R	5 houses and turning area – adjacent Bedford Court, Bedford Row, Unit 4, Laundry Lane, Newport	13 Oct 05	WR	Allowed 7 Mar 06		20.5
157/05		Mr W Button	IC	Condition removing permitted development rights for additional windows or dormer windows – 17 Albert Road, Cowes	13 Oct 05	WR	Dismissed 2 Feb 06		16
11532/F P/115/05		Lambournes	R	3 storey extension to form 3 flats – adjacent 21 Fairlee Road, Newport	21 Oct 05	WR	Dismissed 9 Feb 06		16
P/00119/05		Lambournes	RL	Listed building consent application as above	21 Oct 05	WR	Dismissed 9 Feb 06		16
26860 P/221/05		Mr & Mrs D White	R	Bungalow – The Glen, Heathfield Road, Bembridge	14 Oct 05	WR	Dismissed 20 Feb 06		18.5
E/26713		Mr M A Brittan	E	Change of use of land from agricultural to residential/agricultural- Cuddles Corner, Roud, Ventnor	11 Oct 05	WR	Dismissed 1 Feb 06		16
P/01409/05		Mr S Brown	R	Detached house – 8 Golden Villas, Heathfield Road, Freshwater	21 Oct 05	WR	Dismissed 17 Feb 06		17
P/01506/05		Mr & Mrs D Plucknett	R	Single storey extension with balcony over – 15 The Avenue, Totland Bay	24 Oct 05	WR	Dismissed 17 Feb 06		16.5
P/01517/05		Seafields	RA	2 projecting canopies with logos – 18-19 Union Street, Ryde	24 Oct 05	WR	Allowed 11 Jan 06		11.5
P/01551/04		Mr & Mrs Headington	IC	Removal of permitted development rights preventing extensions – adj 214 Park Road Cowes	26 Oct 05	WR	Withdrawn 9 Feb 06
P/00989/05		Mr C Rackett	R	Demolition of outbuilding and garage and construction of house – 37 Albert Road, Shanklin	26 Oct 05	WR	Dismissed 15 Feb 06		16
P/01256/05		Sigma Homes Ltd	R	Demolition of house, block of 8 flats – 23 Cambridge Road, East Cowes	26 Oct 05	WR	Dismissed 15 Feb 06		16
P/001584/05		Mr M Pittard	R	Change of use from 3 holiday flats to 3 permanent residential flats – Old School House, Church Road, Shanklin	1 Nov 05	WR
E/10723/J		Mr Coventry	E	Change of use from agricultural land to agricultural and residential – Lower Luton Farm, Pallance Lane, Northwood	2 Nov 05	H 6 Jun 06
P/00482/05		Mrs S Woodford	R	Demolition of house; construction of 12 dwellings – 66 Foreland Road, Bembridge	7 Nov 05	WR
P/00719/05		Mr A Attrill	R	Stable block and access – OS parcel 1562, north side of Forest Road, Newport	8 Nov 05	WR	Allowed 17 Mar 06		18.5
P/01469/05		Mr I McCulloch	R	Vehicular access and hardstanding – Orchardleigh, Newport Road, Whitwell	9 Nov 05	WR	Dismissed 23 Feb 06		15
P/00510/05		Mr J Bull	R	2 storey extension to form 4 one bedroomed flats – 10 Ash Grove, Cowes	10 Nov 05	WR	Dismissed 17 Feb 06		14
E/11503/F		Mr J Smith	E	Formation of vehicular access and hardstanding – 17 Star Street, Ryde	11 Nov 05	WR
P/01673/05		Mr J Dart	R	Alterations to provide separate facilities for manager and restaurant – 31 Marsh Road, Gurnard	17 Nov 05	WR	Allowed 9 Mar 06		16
P/0877/05		Mrs W Pledge	R	Vehicular access and hardstanding – 71 Clatterford Road, Carisbrooke	18 Nov 05	WR	Dismissed 23 Feb 06		14
P/01532/05		Mrs R Elliott	R	Dwelling – 70 Fitzroy Street, Sandown	24 Nov 05	WR
P/01224/04		Mr D Moore	R	Demolition of garage; construction of bungalow – Monkton Mead, Tennyson Road, Freshwater	24 Nov 05	WR
P/01846/05		Mrs J Statom	R	Demolition of bungalow, construction of 3 bungalows and access – 24 Beechcroft Drive, Wootton Bridge	1 Dec 05	WR
P/00703/05		Mr R Kingsland	R	Retention of car port and alterations to vehicular access – 53 Upton Road, Ryde	5 Dec 05	WR
P/01392/05		Mr A Wilkes	R	Demolition of garage; terrace of 3 town houses – 2 Parkhurst Road, Newport	6 Dec 05	WR
P/01973/05	Mr & Mrs Twyman		R	Demolition of workshop, construction of bungalow – adj Flora Rosa, Rew Street, Cowes	8 Dec 05	WR
P/01983/05	Sigma Homes Ltd		R	Demolition of house, construction of block of 8 flats – 23 Cambridge Road, East Cowes	23 Dec 05	WR
P/0865/05	Mr & Mrs Bass		IC	Obscured glazed windows – Kintore Court, Broadway, Sandown	29 Dec 05	WR
P/01474/05	Mrs J Williams		R	2 porches and 2 storey rear extension – Sunnyside Farm, Whitwell Road, Godshill	3 Jan 06	WR	Allowed 7 Apr 06	13.5
P/01822/05	Redstone Properties		R	Demolition of garage block, construction of terrace of 4 houses – land rear of 33 and 35 Albany Road, fronting Catherine Terrace, Newport	3 Jan 06	WR
P/0246/05	Mrs J Quick		R	Retention of 1.68m high fence and gate – 134 Howgate Road, Bembridge	3 Jan 06	WR
P/01319/05	Mr R Spencer		R	Stable block and tackroom – OS parcel 6340, adj The Grange, Staplers Road, Wootton	3 Jan 06	WR

NEW APPEALS LODGED THIS QUARTER (1 JANUARY 2006 to 31 MARCH 2006)
Ref	Appellant	Type	Details/site	Appeal Start Date	Procedure/ date of H/I (if known)	Appeal decision and date	Overall duration of appeal (in weeks)
P/02104/04	Mr J Tilden Smith	R	Demolition of house, 3-4 storey block to form 14 flats – 26 Bellevue Road, Ryde	12 Jan 06	WR
P/02074/04	Mr J Tilden Smith	RC	Conservation area consent application as above	12 Jan 06	WR
P/1864/05	Mr J Tilden Smith	R	Demolition of house, 3 storey block with rooms in roof to form 14 flats – 26 Bellevue Road, Ryde	12 Jan 06	WR
P/1867/05	Mr J Tilden Smith	RC	Conservation area consent application as above	12 Jan 06	WR
P/1890/05	Ms A Fitzgerald	R	Detached double garage with living accommodation over – Little Gatcombe Farm, Gatcombe	19 Jan 06	WR
P/1419/05	Maritime & Leisure	R	Conversion of part of ground floor workshop/storage area to retail – Harbour Office, The Duver, St Helens	20 Jan 06	WR
P/1995/05	Mr & Mrs A Bridger	R	COU from agricultural land to private garden – rear of South Place, Newport Road and 1 Downside Avenue, Niton	23 Jan 06	WR
P/1981/05	Mr & Mrs Adams	R	Detached house – adjacent 1 Brookfield Gardens, Ryde	23 Jan 06	WR
P/1478/05	Roseberry (Yarmouth) Ltd	R	Conversion of lower ground floor parking areas into 4 apartmentments – Fort Warden Heights, Hurst Point Road, Totland Bay	27 Jan 06	I
Ref	Appellant	Type	Details/site	Appeal Start Date	Procedure/ date of H/I (if known)	Appeal decision and date	Overall duration of appeal (in weeks)
P/649/05	Isle of Wight Properties Ltd	R	Demolition of building, erection of 3-6 storey block to form 8 flats – Beachlands, Esplanade, Ventnor	7 Feb 06	WR
P/2160/05	Mr D Vale	R	Continued temporary use of former garden centre for display and sale of motor vehicles – Arreton Garden and Aquatic Centre, Hale Common, Arreton	7 Feb 06	WR
P/951/05	Mr K R White	R	Demolition of buildings, new dwelling – Bartletts Green Farm, Brading Road, Ryde	9 Feb 06	WR
P/1948/05	Mr & Mrs P Sellers	R	Single storey extension – The Cedar House, Hamstead Road, Cranmore	16 Feb 06	WR
P/2295/05	Mr R Webster	R	Vehicular access and hardstanding – 181 Sandown Road, Shanklin	28 Feb 06	WR
P/1967/05	Mr P S Newland	RA	2 non illuminated banner signs – Land at access to Lake Industrial Way, Sandown	2 Mar 06	WR
P/01885/05	Barratt (Southampton) Ltd	R	Residential and employment development – Kingston Farm Lane/Cadets Walk/Kinslea Park/Beatrice Avenue/East Cowes Power Station, East Cowes	8 Mar 06	I
P/1387/05	Mr G Canovan	R	Vehicular access and hardstanding – 31 New Road, Brading	8 Mar 06	WR
P/1903/05	Mr G Boynton	R	Garage – 2 Pondwell Close, Ryde	15 Mar 06	WR
P/4325/05	Mornington LLP	R	3 pairs of semi- detached houses, 1 detached house and 4 storey block of 11 flats – site of Mornington, Mornington Road, Cowes	16 Mar 06	H
Ref	Appellant	Type	Details/site	Appeal Start Date	Procedure/ date of H/I (if known)	Appeal decision and date	Overall duration of appeal (in weeks)
P/2043/05	Mr A Johnson	R	End of terrace house – adj 9 Orchard Mews, Staplers Road, Newport	17 Mar 06	WR
P/2278/05	Ms K Truelove	R	Bungalow – land adj Silver Birches, Main Road, Havenstreet	17 Mar 06	WR
P/1766/05	Mr C Piper	R	Demolition of garage, new dwelling - adj United Reformed Church, Guyers Road, Freshwater	20 Mar 06	WR
P/1489/05	Mr K Priest	R	Dwelling – adj Collingtree, Alum Bay New Road, Totland Bay	20 Mar 06	WR
P/2406	Woolworths plc	RA	Illuminated fascia signs and illuminated projecting sign – Woolworths, 104 High Street, Newport	27 Mar 06	WR
P/131/06	Property Management Services (South) Ltd	R	Bungalow – adj Lake View, Main Road, Rookley	29 Mar 06	WR
P/270/06	Woolworths plc	RA	Illuminated fascia sign and illuminated projecting sign – Woolworths, 160-161 High Street, Ryde	31 Mar 06	WR
P/1678/05	Dr D Mairs	R	Single storey extension, balconies – West Afton, Wilmingham Lane, Freshwater	7 Apr 06	WR
P/2096/05	Mr S Howe	R	Dwelling – between 308 and 316 Gunville Road, Newport	7 Apr 06	WR
P/2280/05	Mr B Harvey	R	Retention of agricultural building for use as chemical store – Couthy Butt, Downcourt Farm, Whitwell	13 Apr 06
P/1206/05	Mr & Mrs Jolliffe	IC	Dwelling – 11a Church Road, Binstead	Awaiting validation
Ref	Appellant	Type	Details/site	Appeal Start Date	Procedure/ date of H/I (if known)	Appeal decision and date	Overall duration of appeal (in weeks)
P/306/06	Mr R Latter	E	COU from art gallery to wine bar, Foresters Hall, High Street, Yarmouth	Awaiting validation
P/306/06	Mr P Price	E	COU from art gallery to wine bar, Foresters Hall, High Street, Yarmouth	Awaiting validation
P/00347/06	Mr B Harvey	E	Renovation works to derelict building – Couthy Butt, Downcourt Farm, St Catherines Down, Whitwll	Awaiting validation
P/0041-/06	Ms T Morris	E	Formation of hardstanding and COU from agriculture to storage associated with haulage business – Park Place Farm, Calbourne Road, Newport	Out of time
P/2059/05	Mr R Margey	R	Hardstanding and vehicular access – 39 Fishbourne Lane, Ryde	Awaiting validation
P/130/06	Cromwell Country Homes Ltd	R	4 flats – 49 Cambridge Road, East Cowes	Awaiting validation
P/2161/05	Ms T Morris	R	Continued use of land for expansion of contractors depot – Park Place Farm, Calbourne Road, Newport	Awaiting validation
P/1574/05	Mr D Gladwin	R	Vehicular access and hardstanding – 110 Adelaide Grove, East Cowes	Awaiting validation
P/1747/05	Cromwell Country Homes Ltd	R	4 flats – 49 Cambridge Road, East Cowes	Awaiting validation
P/2455/05	Mr & Mrs S Dyer	R	Two maisonettes – adj 21 and 23 School Lane, Newport	Awaiting validation

KEY

Type

R = Refusal of planning permission

RL = Refusal of listed building consent

RC = Refusal of conservation area consent

RA = Refusal of advertisement consent

IC = Imposition of condition on planning permission

ND = Failure to determine application with prescribed period

E= Enforcement notice

Appeal Procedure

WR = written representations

H = hearing

I = public inquiry

SUMMARY OF SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS FOR QUARTER ENDING 31 MARCH 2006

Number of new appeals 38

Number appeals still in progress 58

Number of appeals withdrawn/invalid 2

Number of appeals determined 34

Dismissed 24 (71%)

Allowed 10 (29%)

END OF YEAR REPORT - 1 April 2005 to 31 March 2006

Appeals received

During 2005/2006 there were 143 appeals lodged compared to 114 in 2004/2005. This represents a 25% increase. Nationally, there are no published figures for the number of appeals lodged in 2005/2006.

Appeals determined

During 2005/2006, 143 appeal decisions were issued by the Planning Inspectorate as compared to 74 for the previous year. 8 cases were withdrawn before determination as compared to 9 cases the previous year.

2005/2006 2004/2005

Total appeals dismissed 108.5 (76%) 57.5 (78%)

Total appeals allowed 34.5 (24%) 16.5 (22%)

Nationally, for the period 2004/2005, the number of appeals allowed was 34%. No figures have been published for 2005/2006.

Breakdown of the appeals determined 2005/2006

Appeals against refusals of planning permission (including listed building and conservation area consents) continue to make up the bulk of the caseload.

Refusals 131 (92%)

Enforcement 5 (4%)

Conditions 4 (2%)

Advertisements __3 (2%)

143

Success rate for each class of appeal:

Refusals

Dismissed 102 (78%)

Allowed 29 (22%)

131

Enforcement

Dismissed 4 (80%)

Allowed 1 (20%)

Conditions

Dismissed 2 (50%)

Allowed 2 (50%)