PAPER B2

 

SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS as at 30 JUNE 2006

 

 

Ref

Appellant

Type

Details/site

Appeal

Start Date

 

Procedure/

date of H/I

(if known)

Appeal

decision and

date

Overall

duration

of appeal

(in weeks)

12116/E

P/1835/04

Mr & Mrs Woodford

R

Extension – Little Kitbridge Farm, Forest Road, Newport

2 Feb 05

H

25 May 06

ALLOWED

27 June 06

73

2009/L

P/559/05

Mr R Watkins

R

Amendment to agricultural occupancy condition to allow use as annex - Bagwich Farm, Bagwich Lane, Godshill

17 June 05

H

20 June 06

 

 

8858/X

P/199/05

Peter Robert Harrison 1997

B Settlement

ND

Marine employment, housing, retail, public house/restaurant, hotel, new quay wall – adj River Medina, Cowes

14 July 05

I

 

 

 

10723/G

P/1663/04

Mr M Coventry

R

Agricultural workers dwelling; 12m high wind turbine – Lower Luton Farm, Pallance Lane, Cowes

14 Sept 05

H

6 Jun 06

 

 

E/10723/J

Mr Coventry

E

Change of use from agricultural land to agricultural and residential – Lower Luton Farm, Pallance Lane, Northwood

2 Nov 05

H

6 Jun 06

 

 

P/001584/05

Mr M Pittard

R

Change of use from 3 holiday flats to 3 permanent residential flats – Old School House, Church Road, Shanklin

1 Nov 05

WR

 

 

P/00482/05

Mrs S Woodford

R

Demolition of house; construction of 12 dwellings – 66 Foreland Road, Bembridge

7 Nov 05

WR

 

 

E/11503/F

Mr J Smith

E

Formation of vehicular access and hardstanding – 17 Star Street, Ryde

11 Nov 05

WR

 

 

P/01532/05

Mrs R Elliott

R

Dwelling – 70 Fitzroy Street, Sandown

24 Nov 05

WR

DISMISSED

30 May 06

27

P/01224/04

Mr D Moore

R

Demolition of garage; construction of bungalow – Monkton Mead, Tennyson Road, Freshwater

24 Nov 05

WR

 

 

P/01846/05

Mrs J Statom

R

Demolition of bungalow, construction of 3 bungalows and access – 24 Beechcroft Drive, Wootton Bridge

1 Dec 05

WR

DISMISSED

3 May 06

22

P/00703/05

Mr R Kingsland

R

Retention of car port and alterations to vehicular access – 53 Upton Road, Ryde

5 Dec 05

WR

DISMISSED

19 May 06

23.5

P/01392/05

Mr A Wilkes

R

Demolition of garage; terrace of 3 town houses – 2 Parkhurst Road, Newport

6 Dec 05

WR

DISMISSED

2 May 06

21

P/01973/05

Mr & Mrs Twyman

R

Demolition of workshop, construction of bungalow – adj Flora Rosa, Rew Street, Cowes

8 Dec 05

WR

DISMISSED

2 May 06

20.5

P/01983/05

Sigma Homes Ltd

R

Demolition of house, construction of block of 8 flats – 23 Cambridge Road, East Cowes

23 Dec 05

WR

DISMISSED

4  May 06

19

P/0865/05

Mr & Mrs Bass

IC

Obscured glazed windows – Kintore Court, Broadway, Sandown

29 Dec 05

WR

DISMISSED

20 April 06

16

P/01822/05

Redstone Properties

R

Demolition of garage block, construction of terrace of 4 houses – land rear of 33 and 35 Albany Road, fronting Catherine Terrace, Newport

3 Jan 06

WR

ALLOWED

15 May 06

19

P/0246/05

Mrs J Quick

R

Retention of 1.68m high fence and gate – 134 Howgate Road, Bembridge

3 Jan 06

WR

ALLOWED

24 April 06

16

P/01319/05

Mr R Spencer

R

Stable block and tackroom – OS parcel 6340, adj The Grange, Staplers Road, Wootton

3 Jan 06

WR

DISMISSED

15 May 06

19

P/02104/04

Mr J Tilden Smith

R

Demolition of house, 3-4 storey block to form 14 flats – 26 Bellevue Road, Ryde

12 Jan 06

WR

DISMISSED

3 May 06

16

P/02074/04

Mr J Tilden Smith

RC

Conservation area consent application as above

12 Jan 06

WR

DISMISSED

3 May 06

16

P/1864/05

Mr J Tilden Smith

R

Demolition of house, 3 storey block with rooms in roof to form 14 flats – 26 Bellevue Road, Ryde

12 Jan 06

WR

DISMISSED

3 May 06

16

P/1867/05

Mr J Tilden Smith

RC

Conservation area consent application as above

12 Jan 06

WR

DISMISSED

3 May 06

16

P/1890/05

Ms A Fitzgerald

R

Detached double garage with living accommodation over – Little Gatcombe Farm, Gatcombe

19 Jan 06

WR

DISMISSED

15 June 06

21

P/1419/05

Maritime & Leisure

R

Conversion of part of ground floor workshop/storage area to retail – Harbour Office, The Duver, St Helens

20 Jan 06

WR

ALLOWED

15 June 06

21

P/1995/05

Mr & Mrs A Bridger

R

COU from agricultural land to private garden – rear of South Place, Newport Road and 1 Downside Avenue, Niton

23 Jan 06

WR

DISMISSED

21 June 06

21

P/1981/05

Mr & Mrs Adams

R

Detached house – adjacent 1 Brookfield Gardens, Ryde

 

 

 

23 Jan 06

WR

DISMISSED

27 June 06

22

P/1478/05

Roseberry (Yarmouth) Ltd

R

Conversion of lower ground floor parking areas into 4 apartmentments – Fort Warden Heights, Hurst Point Road, Totland Bay

27 Jan 06

I

 

 

P/649/05

Isle of Wight Properties Ltd

R

Demolition of building, erection of  3-6 storey block to form 8 flats – Beachlands, Esplanade, Ventnor

7 Feb 06

WR

 

 

P/2160/05

Mr D Vale

R

Continued temporary use of former garden centre for display and sale of motor vehicles – Arreton Garden and Aquatic Centre, Hale Common, Arreton

7 Feb 06

WR

DISMISSED

22 May 06

15

P/951/05

Mr K R White

R

Demolition of buildings, new dwelling – Bartletts Green Farm, Brading Road, Ryde

9 Feb 06

WR

DISMISSED

25 May 06

15

P/1948/05

Mr & Mrs P Sellers

R

Single storey extension – The Cedar House, Hamstead Road, Cranmore

16 Feb 06

WR

 

 

P/2295/05

Mr R Webster

R

Vehicular access and hardstanding – 181 Sandown Road, Shanklin

28 Feb 06

WR

DISMISSED

14 June 06

15

P/1967/05

Mr P S Newland

RA

2 non illuminated banner signs – Land at access to Lake Industrial Way, Sandown

2 Mar 06

WR

DISMISSED

12 May 06

10

P/01885/05

Barratt (Southampton) Ltd

R

Residential and employment development – Kingston Farm Lane/Cadets Walk/Kinslea Park/Beatrice Avenue/East Cowes Power Station, East Cowes

8 Mar 06

I

 

 

P/1387/05

Mr G Canovan

R

Vehicular access and hardstanding – 31 New Road, Brading

 

8 Mar 06

WR

DISMISSED

19 June 06

15

P/1903/05

Mr G Boynton

R

Garage – 2 Pondwell Close, Ryde

15 Mar 06

WR

 

 

P/4325/05

Mornington LLP

R

3 pairs of semi- detached houses, 1 detached house and 4 storey block of 11 flats – site of Mornington, Mornington Road, Cowes

16 Mar 06

H

12 July 06

 

 

P/2043/05

Mr A Johnson

R

End of terrace house – adj 9 Orchard Mews, Staplers Road, Newport

17 Mar 06

WR

 

 

P/2278/05

Ms K Truelove

R

Bungalow – land adj Silver Birches, Main Road, Havenstreet

17 Mar 06

WR

 

 

P/1766/05

Mr C Piper

R

Demolition of garage, new dwelling - adj United Reformed Church, Guyers Road, Freshwater

WITHDRAWN

 

 

 

P/1489/05

Mr K Priest

R

Dwelling – adj Collingtree, Alum Bay New Road, Totland Bay

20 Mar 06

WR

 

 

P/2406

Woolworths plc

RA

Illuminated fascia signs and illuminated projecting sign – Woolworths, 104 High Street, Newport

27 Mar 06

WR

ALLOWED

12 May 06

7.5

P/131/06

Property Management Services (South) Ltd

R

Bungalow – adj Lake View, Main Road, Rookley

29 Mar 06

WR

 

 

P/270/06

Woolworths plc

RA

Illuminated fascia sign and illuminated projecting sign – Woolworths, 160-161 High Street, Ryde

31 Mar 06

WR

ALLOWED

12 May 06

6

P/1678/05

Dr D Mairs

R

Single storey extension, balconies – West Afton, Wilmingham Lane, Freshwater

7 Apr 06

WR

 

 

P/2096/05

Mr S Howe

R

Dwelling – between 308 and 316 Gunville Road, Newport

7 Apr 06

WR

 

 

P/2280/05

Mr B Harvey

R

Retention of agricultural building for use as chemical store – Couthy Butt, Downcourt Farm, Whitwell

WITHDRAWN

 

 

 

P/1206/05

Mr & Mrs Jolliffe

IC

Dwelling – 11a Church Road, Binstead

WITHDRAWN

 

 

 

P/306/06

Mr R Latter

E

COU from art gallery to wine bar, Foresters Hall, High Street, Yarmouth

2 May 06

WR

 

 

P/306/06

Mr P Price

E

COU from art gallery to wine bar, Foresters Hall, High Street, Yarmouth

2 May 06

WR

 

 

P/00347/06

Mr B Harvey

E

Renovation works to derelict building – Couthy Butt, Downcourt Farm, St Catherines Down, Whitwell

21 June 06

WR

 

 

P/130/06

Cromwell Country Homes Ltd

R

4 flats – 49 Cambridge Road, East Cowes

27 April 06

WR

 

 

P/1747/05

Cromwell Country Homes Ltd

R

4 flats – 49 Cambridge Road, East Cowes

27 April 06

WR

 

 

P/2161/05

Ms T Morris

R

Continued use of land for expansion of contractors depot – Park Place Farm, Calbourne Road, Newport

19 April 06

WR

 

 

P/1574/05

Mr D Gladwin

R

Vehicular access and hardstanding – 110 Adelaide Grove, East Cowes

8 May 06

WR

 

 

P/2455/05

Mr & Mrs S Dyer

R

Two maisonettes – adj 21 and 23 School Lane, Newport

25 May 06

WR

 

 

 

 

NEW APPEALS LODGED THIS QUARTER (1 APRIL 2006 TO 30 JUNE 2006)

P/00397/06

Mornington LLP

R

3 pairs of semi-detached houses, 1 detached house and 3 storey block of 8 flats – Site of Mornington, Mornington Road, Cowes

20 April 06

H

12 July 06

 

 

P/01755/05

Mr & Mrs Payne

R

Alterations and enlargement of 2nd floor window on west elevation to include balcony – Sunset View, Marsh Road, Gurnard

10  May 06

WR

 

 

P/02185/05

Miss L Johnson

R

Alterations and two storey extension to provide two bedrooms – 11 Alvington Manor View, Newport

12 May 06

WR

 

 

P/01714/05

Mrs & Mrs N Mills

R

Bungalow and garage, alterations to vehicular access – rear of 53 Horsebridge Hill, Newport

12 May 06

WR

 

 

P/01819/05

Mrs B Reeves

R

Single storey extension to form annexed living accommodation – Rose Cottage, Newport Road, Apse Heath

18 May 06

WR

 

 

P/01741/05

Mr & Mrs Wavell

R

Variation of condition restricting use of accommodation for holiday purposes only – west of 1 & 2 Old Bakery Mews, High Street, Yarmouth

25 May 06

WR

 

 

P/02319/05

Mr S Kennedy

R

Retention of play equipment – Waverley Hotel, 2 Clatterford Road, Newport

30 May 06

WR

 

 

P/01904/05

Mr K Benham

R

Demolition of conservatory, single storey extension to enlarge lounge – The Laurels, High Street, Seaview

2 June 06

WR

 

 

E/11271/F

Mr & Mrs Kent

E

Change of use of land to multiple residential through siting of 2 caravans – Providence Cottage, Whiteley Bank, Ventnor

2 June 06

WR

 

 

P/00321/06

Mr B Harvey

R

Retention of agricultural storage building – Couthy Butt,  Downcourt Farm, Whitwell

7 June 06

WR

 

 

P/02042/05

Mr & Mrs Oxley

R

Extension to residential curtilage, retention of driveway and parking area, closure of existing access, landscaping and post and rail fence – Summers, Atherfield Road, Atherfield

12 June 06

WR

 

 

P/00480/06

P Airey

R

Detached chalet bungalow – former Southern Water tower site, Mill Road, Bembridge

13 June 06

WR

 

 

P/00386/06

Westmont Properties Isle of Wight Ltd

R

Demolition of dwelling and garage; 2 houses and 4 flats, alterations to vehicular access – 23 Terrace Road, Newport

19 June 06

WR

 

 

P/00525/06

Mr & Mrs D Rouse

R

Conversion of roof space to form en-suite bedroom – 29 Golden Ridge, Freshwater

19 June 06

WR

 

 

P/00427/06

J Bartlett

R

2 dwellings, alterations to vehicular access off Marlborough Road – land adj 91 and rear of 89 Marlborough Road, Ryde

19 June 06

WR

 

 

P/01429/05

Tescos Stores Ltd

R

Retail store, vehicular access alterations – land at junction of High Street and Rectory Drive, Wootton

20 June 06

I

 

 

P/00717/06

D Jeapes

R

Extension to form end of terrace house, 2 Maple Drive, Newport

21 June 06

WR

 

 

E/25835/C

Mr M Pittard

E

Non compliance with holiday occupancy condition – The Old School, Church Road, Shanklin

22 June 06

WR

 

 

E/27194

A Wheeler

E

Erection of timber shed – 1 Albany Road, East Cowes

26 June 06

I

 

 

E/27194

A Wheeler

E

Erection of timber shed within curtilage of listed building – 1 Albany Road, East Cowes

26 June 06

I

 

 

P/00644/06

Mr B Corbin

R

Conservatory/garden room – Knighton Barn, Knighton Shute, Newchurch

26 June 06

WR

 

 

P/00529/06

Mr B Corbin

RL

Listed building consent for conservatory/garden room – Knighton Barn, Knighton Shute, Newchurch

26 June 06

WR

 

 

P/01940/05

Mr C Jago

R

Removal of condition relating to opaque screening – 22 Shore Road, Cowes

27 June 06

WR

 

 

P/01726/05

Mr C Torrens

R

Demolition of garden room; detached building to form annexed accommodation to No 20 Castle Road – land rear of 18-20 Castle Road, Cowes

28 June 06

WR

 

 

P/00388/06

Hepburns Town & Country Planning Partnership

R

2 pairs of semi-detached houses; footpath and parking area – Horseshoe Inn, 353 Newport Road, Cowes

30 June 06

WR

 

 

E/10010/B

Mr & Mrs Oxley

E

Formation of vehicular access and hardstanding – Summers, Atherfield Road, Atherfield

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00352/06

A G Page

R

Fire escape to rear elevation at 2nd floor level to include alterations to window and door – 33 Queens Road, Cowes

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00506/06

Mr & Mrs T Davis

R

Demolition of garage; bungalow with integral garage and vehicular access – Land adj Westward, Westhill Lane, Yarmouth

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00863/06

Mr P Jones

R

Privacy screen and safety railings on existing one storey flat roof – 33 Cambridge Road, East Cowes

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

E/7426/M

Mr & Mrs Marshall

E

Vehicular access and driveway – Chale House, Blythe Shute, Chale

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00499/06

Mr L Booth

R

End of terrace house; vehicular access and parking – Land adj 67 Broadway Crescent, Ryde

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00846/06

Lightwood Property

R

Demolition of dwelling and outline for 14 houses with parking – Kentstone House, Binstead Road, Ryde

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00542/06

Rotapoint Ltd

R

Demolition of part of roof; replacement room and conversion of part of building to form flat – Roundhouse Hotel, 61 George Street, Ryde

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00550/06

Rotapoint Ltd

RL

Listed building consent for demolition of part of roof; replacement room and conversion of part of building to form flat – Roundhouse Hotel, 61 George Street, Ryde

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00625/06

Mr & Mrs S Hall

R

Conservatory – Watergate Farm, Marvel Lane, Newport

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00626/06

Mr & Mrs S Hall

RL

Listed building consent for conservatory – Watergate Farm, Marvel Lane, Newport

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00545/06

Miss J Houghton & Miss L Ramsden

R

Alterations; 2nd floor extension to provide additional living accommodation – 8 The Strand, Ryde

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00266/06

Mr & Mrs P Sibley

R

Chalet bungalow and vehicular access – Hi Profile, Cranmore Avenue, Yarmouth

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00285/06

Dr M Patterson

RLDC

Siting of mobile home – Wolverton Manor, Shorwell

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/02574/05

Mrs V Taylor

R

Demolition of garage; outline for detached house and alterations to vehicular access – Edvale, The Shute, Newchurch

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00341/05

Heritage Properties Ltd

R

3 pairs of semi-detached houses, 3 detached houses, (9 in total), formation of vehicular access and parking provision

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

P/00513/05

Heritage Properties Ltd

RL

Listed building consent for demolition and rebuilding of collapsed wall – land forming part of Egypt House, Egypt Hill, Cowes

Awaiting validation

 

 

 

 

 

KEY

 

 

Type                                                                                                                                                  

R = Refusal of planning permission                                                              

RL = Refusal of listed building consent                                                         

RC = Refusal of conservation area consent                                                 

RA = Refusal of advertisement consent

IC = Imposition of condition on planning permission

ND = Failure to determine application with prescribed period

E= Enforcement notice

RLDC= Refusal for lawful development certificate

 

Appeal Procedure

 

WR = written representations

H = hearing

I = public inquiry

 

 

SUMMARY OF SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS FOR QUARTER ENDING 30 JUNE 2006

                                                                                                                                  

                                                                                

Number of new appeals                        42                       

 

Number appeals still in progress          70                                                              

 

Number of appeals withdrawn/invalid      3                                                                      

 

Number of appeals determined              26                                                                   

            Dismissed       20 (77%)                             

            Allowed               6 (23%)