PAPER B2

INTERIM APPEAL REPORT

(1 April to 31 May 2005)

Summary

Decisions issued (1 April to 31 May 2005) 41

Dismissed 32 (78%)

Allowed 9 (22%)

Number of cases withdrawn 2

Number of cases still in progress 43

Number of cases awaiting validation 9

List of decisions issued (1 April to 31 May 2005)

TCP/20860/B Mr & Mrs P Rikard against refusal for block of 3 flats on land adjacent to 67 West Hill Road, Ryde. DISMISSED

LBC/16062 Dr M Patterson against refusal of listed building consent for 17 storage units, office and hoist inside building at 13 Union Road, Ryde. DISMISSED

TCP/20953/B Stephenson Developments Ltd against refusal for amendment to position of approved block of flats at site of Wilmington, Cliff Road, Totland. DISMISSED

TCP/19159/B Mr & Mrs Brownrigg against refusal for new chalet bungalow on land at Greenacre, Southdown Road, Freshwater Bay. ALLOWED

TCP/414/D Mr & Mrs S Thompson against refusal for dwelling and garage on land rear of White Webbs, The Mall, Totland Bay. DISMISSED

TCP/25943/A Gardner Business Consultancy Services against refusal for mobile catering kiosk on land at The Promenade, Totland Bay. DISMISSED

TCP/15162/A Mr V Jolliffe and Mr S Kennedy against refusal for detached house, parking and vehicular access on land adjacent to 28 School Lane, Carisbrooke, Newport. DISMISSED

TCP/11675/H Mr & Mrs Lovelock against refusal for 10 houses and vehicular access on land adjacent to The Old Dairy Farm, Horsebridge Hill, Newport. DISMISSED

TCP/14040/E Mr & Mrs Brett against refusal for new detached bungalow at Church Cottage, Main Road, Thorley, Yarmouth. DISMISSED

TCP/9561/B Mr S Darch against refusal for new detached house on land adjacent to 2 Ivy Cottages, Cross Road, Lake, Sandown. DISMISSED

TCP/20642/B Mrs S Charlesworth against refusal for siting of caravan at Delysia Stables, Carpenters Road, Brading. DISMISSED

TCP/8462/H Mr D W Parker against refusal for block of 10 flats on site of 66 and 68 Landguard Manor Road, Shanklin. DISMISSED

TCP/26431 Mr P Hillier against refusal for retention of 1.4 metre high boundary fence at 1 Castle Court, St Lawrence. DISMISSED

TCP/19799/A Village Developments against refusal for demolition of existing house and construction of a three storey block of 6 flats at 1 Mayfield Road, East Cowes. DISMISSED

TCP/18855/C Mr R Spencer against refusal for block of 3 stables and tack room at OS parcel 6340, land adjacent The Grange, Staplers Road, Wootton. DISMISSED

TCP/22659/B Mr Hart against refusal for two storey side extension at 17 Great Preston Road, Ryde. DISMISSED

TCP/24506/D Mr M Lawton against refusal for retention of stable block at Burnt House Lane, Sandown. DISMISSED

TCP/2582/C Mr A Wilkes against refusal for 3 new houses on land at rear of 2 Parkhurst Road, Newport. DISMISSED

TCP/19522/D Mr & Mrs S Adams against refusal for a terrace of 4 new dwellings on land at 3 Newport Street, Ryde. ALLOWED

TCP/26455 Mrs A Holbrook against refusal for demolition of garage and 2 new houses on land adjacent to 1 Old Road, East Cowes. DISMISSED

TCP/25978 Clutterbuck-Edwards against refusal for new house on land at junction of Castle Road and Castle Close, Ventnor. DISMISSED

TCP/26531 Mrs J White and Mrs J West against refusal for a new bungalow on land at rear of 16/18 St Georges Road, Shanklin. ALLOWED

TCP/4989/R Mr K Newbery against refusal for new house on land at Nab Wood, Cupressus Avenue, Winford. DISMISSED

TCP/26401 Mr M D Cooper against refusal for change of use of land for the keeping of horses and erection of stable/store at land adjacent to Longwood, Lower Road, Adgestone, Sandown. DISMISSED

TCP/25191/F Mrs S Hicky against refusal for a multi-purpose agricultural building at Durrants Farm, Colemans Lane, Porchfield. ALLOWED

TCP/25191/H Mrs S Hicky against refusal for replacement farmhouse at Durrants Farm, Colemans Lane, Porchfield. DISMISSED

TCP/19749/B Mr R Newnham against refusal for extension at 2 Bettesworth Road, Ryde. ALLOWED

TCP/17628/D Mr C Reynolds against refusal for new dwelling on land adjaent to 146 Gunville Road, Newport. ALLOWED

TCP/05685/N Mr D Wood against refusal for new dwelling at Queensberry, 37 Newport Road, Godshill. ALLOWED

TCP/11503/P Mr J Smith against refusal for off road parking at 17 Star Street, Ryde. DISMISSED

TCP/23550/B Mr & Mrs R Spencer against refusal for new bungalow with car parking on land adjacent to 106 Pallance Road, Northwood, Cowes. DISMISSED

TCP/9755/J Mr N Greenhalgh against refusal for a detached house to replace existing detached workshop/builders’ yard at 69A Pelham Road, Cowes. DISMISSED

E/15171/F Mr I Cantelo against enforcement notice relating to reconstruction of former mill at Cheeks Farm, Merstone Lane, Merstone. DISMISSED

TCP/25821/A Mr N Greenhalgh against a detached bungalow on land to the rear of 3 Trinity Road, Ventnor. DISMISSED

TCP/26277 Mr & Mrs K Baker against refusal for conservatory at 18 Foxhills, Ventnor. ALLOWED

TCP/26039/B Mr M Cave against refusal for pair of semi-detached houses land to the rear of 91/93 Elm Grove, Newport. DISMISSED

TCP/26702 Mr T Payne against refusal for vehicular access and hardstanding at 59 Castle Road, Newport. ALLOWED

TCP/25666/E Mr R Saunders against refusal for vehicular access and hardstanding at Flora Cottage, Morton Road, Brading. DISMISSED

TCP/13102/S Mr N Drysdale against refusal for detached bungalow on land adjacent to 47 Melville Street, Ryde. DISMISSED

TCP/11271/E Mr W Kent against refusal for detached house land adjacent to Providence Cottage, Whiteley Bank. DISMISSED

TCP/22049/B Mr S de Belder against refusal for dwelling and garage on land between 4 St Edmunds Walk and Sans Souci, New Road, Wootton. DISMISSED

Appeals withdrawn

TCP/02402/S Mr & Mrs Scott-Hake against refusal for conversion of hotel into care home at Westfield Hotel, 17 Broadway, Sandown.

E/25066/C Mr B Lancaster against enforcement notice relating to general storage unrelated to agriculture at stables, part OS parcel 0091 and 0072, Hulverstone Lane, Hulverstone

Copies of the full decision letters relating to the above appeals may be obtained from the Appeals Officer (Mrs J Kendall) (extension 3572) at Planning Services, Seaclose, Fairlee Road, Newport