|
Ref |
Appellant |
Type |
Details/site |
Appeal Start Date |
Procedure/ date of H/I (if known) |
Appeal decision and date |
Overall duration of appeal (in weeks) |
|
16015/L P/02255/03 |
George Jenkins Transport Ltd |
IC |
Condition limiting number of tractor/trailer units to 27 at approved new building - Bigbury Farm, Alverstone Road, Apse Heath |
22 Jul 04 |
H 9 Aug 05 |
Allowed 31 Aug 05 |
58 |
|
22148/B P/00628/04 |
Mr J A Dempsey |
R |
Single storey extension to stable block – Birchmore Stables, Birchmore Lane, Blackwater |
9 Aug 04 |
H 14 Sept 05 |
Dismissed 28 Sept 05 |
54 |
|
6741/E P/02344/02 |
Mr & Mrs Board |
R |
Extension – 1 Baring Drive, Cowes |
18 Aug 04 |
H 17 Aug 05 |
Dismissed 18 Aug 05 |
56 |
|
1272/E P/00994/04 |
B B Developments |
R |
Condition requiring 2 affordable housing units at approved housing development scheme of 9 houses -Land at Clematis Cottage and Berrylands, Heathfield Road, Bembridge |
19 Aug 04 |
H 13 Sept 05 |
Withdrawn 22 Jul 05 |
|
|
E/25011/A |
Mr & Mrs A Court |
E |
Increased height of house – Edina, Mill Road, Yarmouth |
7 Oct 04 |
I 25 Jan 06 |
|
|
|
14948/G P/2436/03 |
Ms C Frankl-Bertram |
R |
Demolition of 6 chalets and construction of 3 detached houses – 1-6 Beach Chalets, Marsh Road, Gurnard |
14 Oct 04 |
H 19 Oct 05 |
|
|
|
10471/E P/968/04 |
Mrs Hall |
R |
Retention of windbreak netting – Timber, Undercliff Drive, St Lawrence |
4 Nov 04 |
WR |
|
|
|
4323/T P/1470/04 |
Mr & Mrs Locke |
RL |
Demolition of barn and construction of annex; 3 dormer windows to main house – Dodpit House, Dodpits Lane, Newbridge |
15 Dec 04 |
H |
|
|
|
4323/U P/1469/04 |
Mr & Mrs Locke |
RL |
Listed building application as above |
15 Dec 04 |
H |
|
|
|
12116/E P/1835/04 |
Mr & Mrs Woodford |
R |
Extension – Little Kitbridge Farm, Forest Road, Newport |
2 Feb 05 |
H |
|
|
|
E/10471/F |
Mrs Hall |
E |
Erection of windbreak netting – Timber Undercliff Drive, St Lawrence |
3 Feb 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
20347/A P/1548/04 |
Mr K Blamey & Mrs K Woolfenden |
R |
Terrace of 3 houses – land adjacent Halberry House, Halberry Lane, Newport |
24 Feb 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 7 July 05 |
19 |
|
19799/B P/2190/04 |
Village Developments |
R |
Demolition of existing house, 2 storey block of 4 flats – 1 Mayfield Road, East Cowes |
11 Mar 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 1 July 05 |
16 |
|
16952/B P/43/05 |
Mr H A Pritchard |
R |
Conversion of 3 flats to single dwelling – 30 John Street, Ryde |
15 Mar 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 6 July 05 |
16 |
|
26662 P/2268/04 |
Mr A Thorne |
R |
Vehicular access and hardstanding – 44 Yarborough Road, East Cowes |
16 Mar 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 7 July 05 |
16 |
|
17024/K P/2473/04 |
Mr P Waterhouse |
R |
Extension – Southford Mill, Southford Lane, Whitwell |
16 Mar 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 6 July 05 |
16 |
|
26535 P/1771/04 |
Mr M Pittard |
R |
Single storey extension to existing detached guest accommodation building – Palmers Brook House, Park Road, Wootton Bridge |
17 Mar 05 |
WR |
Allowed 2 Sept 05 |
24 |
|
24189/S P/1228/04 |
Spithead Estates Ltd |
R |
Continued use of land for open plant storage – Spithead Business Centre, Newport Road, Lake |
5 Apr 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 31 Aug 05 |
20 |
|
26700 P/02270/04 |
Mr T McLinden |
R |
Demolition of former tea room building and erection of terrace of 4 holiday cottages – adj The Coach House, Manor Road, Shanklin |
8 Apr 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 31 Aug 05 |
25 |
|
19137/U P/20/05 |
Hamble Homes Ltd |
R |
Additional door and window – Plot 2, Chillerton Farm Barns, Main Road, Chillerton |
8 Apr 05 |
WR |
Allowed 9 Aug 05 |
17 |
|
14948 P/1830/05 |
Ms E Cooke |
R |
Demolition of chalet and construction of bungalow – 10 Beachside Chalets, Marsh Road, Gurnard |
12 Apr 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 12 Aug 05 |
13 |
|
26593 P/2010/04 |
Mr P Blow |
R |
Detached garage/store – Newholme, Langridge, Newchurch |
12 Apr 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 11 Aug 05 |
17 |
|
23881/A P/2576/04 |
Mr C Blenkinsop |
R |
Extension to roof – 6 Marsh Road, Gurnard |
12 Apr 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 12 Aug 05 |
13 |
|
15178/A P/2525/04 |
Mr & Mrs Hayward |
R |
Extension – 74 Wilton Road, Shanklin |
13 Apr 05 |
WR |
Allowed 26 Aug 05 |
19 |
|
24189/T P/2340/04 |
Spithead Estates Ltd |
R |
Use of land for storage of containers – Spithead Business Centre, Newport Road, Lake |
14 Apr 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 31 Aug 05 |
20 |
|
1680/K P/2422/04 |
Mrs S Donaldson |
R |
Replacement windows to first floor flat – 1 Wheatsheaf Lane, Yarmouth |
20 Apr 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 26 Aug 05 |
19 |
|
25759/A P/1964/04 |
Mr H Gange |
R |
Bungalow and garage – adj 6 Blackerry Lane, Cowes |
25 Apr 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 26 Aug 05 |
18 |
|
12070/A P/2244/04 |
Mr & Mrs Leech |
R |
Detached house – adj 208 Mill Hill Road, Cowes |
4 May 05 |
WR |
Allowed 26 Aug 05 |
16 |
|
26833 P/174/05 |
Mr & Mrs Buckett |
R |
Detached house – adj 30 Bellmead Lane, Newport |
19 May 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
22104/C P/1295/04 |
Mr A Button |
IC |
Condition removing permitted development rights for additional windows on approved pair of semi-detached houses – 68 Albert Street, Gurnard |
23 May 05 |
WR |
Allowed 19 Aug 05 |
13 |
|
10228/S P/2169/04 |
Mr J Hetherington |
R |
Demolition of dwelling and construction of 2 x 3 storey blocks of 8 flats and 1 house – Jalna, Appley Road, Ryde |
25 May 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 30 Sep 05 |
19 |
|
10228/T P/2323/04 |
Mr J Hetherington |
RC |
Conservation Area Consent application as above |
25 May 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 30 Sept 05 |
19 |
|
4323/W P/170/05 |
Mr & Mrs Locke |
R |
Demolition of barn and construction of storage building; 3 dormer windows to main house – Dodpits House, Dodpits Lane, Newbridge |
26 May 05 |
H |
|
|
|
4323/V P/169/05 |
Mr & Mrs Locke |
RL |
Listed building consent application as above |
26 May 05 |
H |
|
|
|
26801 P/2672/04 |
Mr T Mosdell & Ms K Webb |
R |
Extension – 29 Parkway, Apse Heath, Sandown |
26 May 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 19 Aug 05 |
12 |
|
17642/F P/232/05 |
Mr & Mrs Abbott |
R |
Demolition of owners’ accommodation chalets and construction of dwelling – Brighstone Holiday Centre, Military Road, Brighstone |
27 May 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 29 Sept 05 |
18 |
|
26783 P/2661/04 |
Mr & Mrs Hughes |
R |
Detached house – adj 2 Brookfield House, Vicarage Walk, Newport |
7 June 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 12 Sept 05 |
14 |
|
19255/B P/2312/04 |
Mr & Mrs Dye |
R |
Detached house – adj Lea Cottage, Pound Green, Freshwater |
8 June 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 30 Sept 05 |
17 |
|
E/25508/C |
Mr T Smith |
E |
COU of agricultural land to motocross site – Gore Basin, Downend Road, Newport |
10 June 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
17752/E P/844/04 |
Hampshire Securities Ltd |
R |
Demolition of old rectory and construction of 3 storey block of 10 flats – 73 Cambridge Road, East Cowes |
13 June 05 |
WR |
Allowed 28 Sept 05 |
16 |
|
114/N P/556/05 |
Morrison plc |
RA |
New and replacement signage – Morrisons Store, South Street, Newport |
14 June 05 |
WR |
Part allowed Part dismissed 5 Aug 05 |
7 |
|
26648 P/2155/04 |
Mr Chamberlain |
R |
Detached house – adj Panorama, Alverstone Road, Apse Heath |
13 June 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 12 Sept 05 |
13 |
|
25888/A P/1482/04 |
Mr & Mrs Gibbons |
R |
Detached bungalow – rear of 14 St Johns Crescent, Sandown |
14 June 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
26068/A P/31/05 |
Mr & Mrs C Knight |
R |
Detached house – rear of Glenfield, Binstead Hill, Ryde |
14 June 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 28 Sept 05 |
16 |
|
2009/L P/559/05 |
Mr R Watkins |
R |
Amendment to agricultural occupancy condition to allow use as annex - Bagwich Farm, Bagwich Lane, Godshill |
17 June 05 |
H |
|
|
|
618/D P/2246/04 |
Mr & Mrs Firstbrook |
IC |
Condition removing permitted development rights for additional windows/dormers on approved extension - Seaway, Swains Road, Bembridge |
17 June 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
26833/A P/692/05 |
Mr & Mrs Buckett |
R |
Bungalow – adj 30 Bellmead Lane, Newport |
17 June 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
26969 P/693/05 |
Mr & Mrs Adams |
R |
Detached house – adj 1 Brookfield Gardens, Ryde |
29 June 05 |
WR |
Dismissed 28 Sept 05 |
13 |
|
26069/A P/443/05 |
Mrs H Turner |
R |
Pair of semi-detached houses – rear of 22-24 Whitepit Lane, Newport |
4 July 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
2215/U P/2148/04 |
Mrs T Hayles |
R |
Porch and alterations, The Old Dairy, Gusters Shute, Calbourne |
4 July 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
9075/B P/648/05 |
Mr R Turner |
R |
Demolition of office/workshop and construction of end terrace house – 1a Yarborough Road, East Cowes |
6 July 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
22092/D P/604/05 |
Hall & Woodhouse Ltd |
R |
Retention of down-lighters to access drive – Clarendon Hotel & White House Inn, Church Place, Chale |
7 July 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
E/26102/B |
Mrs M Newnham |
E |
Siting of residential caravan – 1 Sheep Lane Cottages, Blythe Shute, Chale |
13 July 05 |
I 29 Nov 05 |
|
|
|
E/20443/K |
Mrs M Newham |
E |
Siting of residential caravan -Hawthorne Manor Farm, Chale Green |
13 July 05 |
I 29 Nov 05 |
|
|
|
8858/X P/199/05 |
Peter Robert Harrison 1997 B Settlement |
ND |
Marine employment, housing, retail, public house/restaurant, hotel, new quay wall – adj River Medina, Cowes |
14 July 05 |
I |
|
|
|
NEW APPEALS LODGED THIS QUARTER (1 JULY 05 to 30
SEPTEMBER 05) |
|||||||
|
P220/05 |
Construction Control Services Ltd |
R |
Removal of condition to allow uPVC windows – Clarendon Press Building, Market Street, Ventnor |
11 July 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
P/680/05 |
Mr S Knight |
R |
Extensions and alterations to form additional dwelling and conversion of shop and existing living accommodation in a dwelling – 32 Lake Hill, Sandown |
12 July 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
P/936/05 |
Mr N Greenhalgh |
R |
Demolition of workshop and construction of bungalow – land rear of 69 Pelham Road, Cowes |
18 July 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
26427/A P/2539/04 |
Mr & Mrs Cooper |
R |
Shed – The Old Radio Station, Castlehaven Lane, Niton |
22 July 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
16511/L P/642/05 |
Mr & Mrs Hall |
R |
Single storey extension – Watergate Farm, Marvel Lane, Newport |
28 July 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
16511/K P/643/05 |
Mr & Mrs Hall |
RL |
Listed building consent application as above |
28 July 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
25011/A P/19/05 |
Mr & Mrs A Court |
R |
Retention of dwelling as constructed- Edina, Mill Road, Yarmouth |
28 July 05 |
I 25 Jan 06 |
|
|
|
7714/A P/898/05 |
Mr & Mrs Proctor |
R |
Detached dwelling and parking – land at and rear of Ivy Cottage and fronting New Road, Brading |
28 July 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
26135/B P/762/05 |
Mr P Lipscombe |
R |
Detached house – adjacent 21 Beatrice Avenue, East Cowes |
28 July 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
12182/J P/1808/04 |
Mr N P Allen |
R |
Demolition of garage/workshop and construction of detached house |
4 Aug 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
25836/C P/1808/04 |
Park Resorts Ltd |
R |
14 static caravan bases – Thorness Bay Holiday Park, Thorness Lane, Cowes |
5 Aug 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
26613 P/2067/04 |
K Hamer |
R |
Retention of reinstatement of access and new access road – land at Westover Park, Lynch Lane, Calbourne |
15 Aug 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
23063/B P/2631/04 |
Mr M Little |
R |
Conversion of roof and alterations to include dormer window to extend living accommodation – 75 Leeson Road, Ventnor |
17 Aug 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
11706/F P/109/05 |
Mr & Mrs M Allard |
R |
Alterations and extension – 1 Upon Cottages, Stroud Wood Road, Ryde |
17 Aug 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
17589/C P/478/05 |
Mr K Osborn |
R |
Retention and completion of vehicular access – Adela, Kemming Road, Whitwell |
23 Aug 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
26982 P/751/05 |
Mr & Mrs G White |
R |
Alterations and 2 storey extension – 141 Perowne Way, Sandown |
25 Aug 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
22980/A P/12/05 |
Mr M Deacon |
R |
End of terrace house – adjacent 29 School Lane, Newport |
26 Aug 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
7970/G P/301/05 |
Mr T Kearney |
R |
Demolition of garage and construction of a pair of semi-detached houses and parking – adjacent 24 Hilton Road, Cowes |
31 Aug 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
22742/E P/2411/04 |
Mr J Barsdell |
R |
Demolition of offices and pump canopy, residential development and alterations to vehicular access – Rookley Auto Point, Main Road, Rookley |
6 Sept 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
22742/F P/2412/04 |
Mr J Barsdell |
R |
Conversion of workshop into 5 flats and 2 houses, retaining wall and parking – Rookley Auto Point, Main Road, Rookley |
6 Sept 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
26412/A P/885/05 |
Techaid Facilities Ltd |
R |
3 & 4 storey block of 8 flats – 16 Union Road, Ryde |
8 Sept 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
969/D P/669/05 |
Mr & Mrs J Sutton & Mr and Mrs G Warren |
R |
Demolition of 2 dwellings and construction of 2 bungalows and 3 terraced houses – 10 and 12 Wyatts Lane, Cowes |
8 Sept 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
4920/X P/00667/05 |
Mrs L Atwood & Mr C Donoclift |
R |
Detached house and garage – adjacent Silverleys, High Street, Godshill |
9 Sept 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
26435/A P/2670/04 |
Mr K Wherry |
R |
Dwelling – adjacent 18 Clarence Road, Newport |
9 Sept 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
2647/C P/1187/05 |
Rotopoint Ltd |
R |
New roof to section of building to provide 2nd floor flat – Roundhouse Hotel, 61 George Street, Ryde |
13 Sept 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
26475/D P/1183/05 |
Rotopoint Ltd |
RL |
Listed building application as above |
13 Sept 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
26950 P/563/05 |
Mr & Mrs Thomson |
R |
Bungalow – adjacent 9 Lanes End, Totland |
13 Sept 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
10723/G P/1663/04 |
Mr M Coventry |
R |
Agricultural workers dwelling; 12m high wind turbine – Lower Luton Farm, Pallance Lane, Cowes |
14 Sept 05 |
H |
|
|
|
26589/A P/669/05 |
Mr J Avey |
R |
Conversion of house into 2 flats and extension to form 2 addition flats – 97 Clarence Road, East Cowes |
23 Sept 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
1443/05 |
Mr A Smallman |
R |
End of terrace house – adjacent 22 Clifford Street, Newport |
10 Oct 05 |
WR |
|
|
|
1172/05 |
Mr & Mrs Proctor |
R |
Dwelling without parking – land at and rear of Ivy Cottage, Church Lane and fronting New Road, Brading |
Awaiting validation |
|
|
|
|
2524/03 |
Mr J Rowlands |
R |
5 houses and turning area – adjacent Bedford Court, Bedford Row, Unit 4, Laundry Lane, Newport |
Awaiting validation |
|
|
|
|
157/05 |
Mr W Button |
IC |
Condition removing permitted development rights for additional windows or dormer windows – 17 Albert Road, Cowes |
Awaiting validation |
|
|
|
|
11532/F P/115/05 |
Lambournes |
R |
3 storey extension to form 3 flats – adjacent 21 Fairlee Road, Newport |
Awaiting validation |
|
|
|
|
26860 P/221/05 |
Mr & Mrs D White |
R |
Bungalow – The Glen, Heathfield Road, Bembridge |
Awaiting validation |
|
|
|
|
A/244/B P/385/05 |
Newport/Carisbrooke Social Ltd |
RA |
Illuminated fascia sign and hanging sign – 34 Orchard Street, Newport |
4 Oct 05 |
|
|
|
|
E/26713 |
Mr M A Brittan |
E |
Change of use of land from agricultural to residential/agricultural- Cuddles Corner, Roud, Ventnor |
Awaiting validation |
|
|
|
KEY |
|
|
Type R = Refusal of planning permission RL = Refusal of listed building consent RC = Refusal of conservation area consent RA = Refusal of advertisement consent IC = Imposition of condition on planning permission ND = Failure to determine application with prescribed period E= Enforcement notice |
Appeal Procedure WR = written representations H = hearing I = public inquiry
|
|
SUMMARY OF SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS FOR QUARTER ENDING 30
SEPTEMBER 2005
Number of new appeals 37 Number appeals still in progress 59 Number of appeals withdrawn 1 Number of appeals determined 32 Dismissed 24.5 (77%) Allowed 7.5 (23%) |